ES2 Newsletter

A Dangerous Intersection

Public policies and public shared values can intersect at unforeseen points.  Too often, these intersections can be negative consequences for all of us.  One collision between policy and public value is welfare regulations and education.

For example, the organization of which I am a part, Welfare Rights Initiative (WRI), sees too many young adult students (often fresh out of high school) told that they cannot attend college because they reside in households receiving welfare. Most of these students are dependents on their parent’s budget, have aged out of foster care, or are on their own for other reasons.

At welfare centers, students are told that work first is NYC’s welfare policy.  This policy is based on the assumption that work and education are conflicting values.  My experiences over the past 17 years with WRI students have only made clear that the two should not be mutually exclusive.  In fact, it’s because our students value work that they’re determined to stay in school and obtain necessary skills and credentials, which would prepare them for paid employment and reduce their dependence on welfare.  NYC’s work first model prioritizes “dead-end” Work Experience Program (WEP) assignments, or “job search” that mostly equates to spending the entire work day in a room with other unemployed peers waiting for a computer. These welfare recipients, instead of opportunities for education, are given training on how to set alarm clocks and “show up” to non-existent jobs.

Our students, who based on existing potential are accepted into Hunter, Baruch, and other 4-year colleges, are forced not to attend because NYC’s welfare policy won’t approve 4-year colleges as a qualifying activity. These students are told they must do job search or WEP.

I am thinking any graduating high schooler who is accepted into Hunter or Baruch ought to have the whole city encouraging them to attend.

Those unaware of the pitfalls of the welfare system insist, of course, that “Work First” is a good policy.  NYS Human Resources Commissioner Robert Doar believes “people should work for any benefit they receive”; others persist that those who need welfare really need some training in dignity and not education.  Many do not question the real reason why welfare roles are down 70%, and believe that this must be a good thing for taxpayers. All this blinds the public to realities – that welfare numbers are down because policies are intolerant. That ordinary people are often caught in extraordinary conditions. That moving permanently out of poverty contributes to increases in economic security for all families and taxpayers.

Recent studies show that attaining college degrees virtually guarantee movement from welfare and out of poverty.  CUNY studies showed that almost 90% of women receiving welfare who attained a college degree moved permanently out of poverty. The US Department of Labor shows that higher levels of education increase earnings: bachelor’s degree recipients earn $1,012 a week from employment, compared to high school or GED graduates at $618 a week.  That is a difference of $394 per week, or $20,488 a year.  In addition, college graduates get jobs that last.

According to January 2010 figures, the rate of unemployment during this current economic downturn was highest for people without a college degree: an education level less than high school held a whopping 15.2% unemployment rate; compared to the 4.9% unemployment rate of bachelor’s degree or higher.

Despite these facts, current city and state welfare policy has driven over 20,000 students receiving public assistance away from CUNY. It appears that welfare reform paradoxically closed the door on the best-known route out of poverty–access to education from GED to college.

NYC’s welfare policy, one that de-values access to education across the spectrum, currently dangerously intersects with New York State’s future. Our harsh economic times insist we cannot afford to be passive bystanders while this collision takes place. The New York State constitution demands that we provide for the poor, and the work first program claims its priority is to help people receiving welfare move to employment. How is blocking access to higher education helping either of these missions?

Here’s what can be done right now in NYC and NYS:

  • Change NYC’s current 35/40 hour work requirements to 20/30 hours. Federal and state laws require no more than 20 hours of work activity for families with children under the age of 6, and 30 hours for all others.
  • Count Homework assignments in higher education and other programs towards the work requirement.  Federal law allows it.  Other states count homework and report great outcomes.
  • Fully implement the Work-study/internship law.
  • Support the NYS legislature to pass S2323/A2471 which broadens access to education from ABE through to college and counts 4-year college as participation requirement conforming to current federal regulations.

Signed and authored by:

Dillonna C. Lewis
Co-Executive Director
Welfare Rights Initiative (WRI)
Hunter College
695 Park Avenue, Room E1222
New York, NY  10065
Phone: 212-650-3569
Fax: 212-650-3845


Jessica Song
Policy, Advocacy & Research
Federation of Protestant Welfare Agencies
Phone: (212) 777-4800  x 315


Maureen Lane
Co-Executive Director
Welfare Rights Initiative (WRI)
Hunter College
695 Park Avenue, Room TH 207
New York, NY  10065
Phone: 212-650-3494
Fax: 212-650-3845
This entry was posted in Call to Action, Legislation, Policy. Bookmark the permalink.

913 Responses to ES2 Newsletter

  1. Pingback: URL

  2. Pingback: Reliant Energy Reviews

  3. Pingback: binance registration

  4. Pingback: dewaqq

  5. Pingback: replica rolex cellini

  6. Pingback: cvvshop

  7. Pingback: ثبت نام در بت فوروارد

  8. Pingback: Beställ OxyContin i Sverige

  9. Pingback: Köp OxyContin I sverige

  10. Pingback: maryland crabs

  11. Pingback: ห่วย

  12. Pingback: Roofers in Millbrook AL

  13. Pingback: how much did ikea pay for taskrabbit

  14. Pingback: kardinal stick

  15. Pingback: Buy Handguns online

  16. Pingback: best cvv site

  17. Pingback: 메이저놀이터

  18. Pingback: Kitchen and Bathroom Remodeling Buckhead Atlanta/Click Here

  19. Pingback:

  20. Pingback: cialis canada francais

  21. Pingback: acheter viagra wikipedia

  22. Pingback: viagra fuck australia

  23. Pingback: Penis Envy Mushroom

  24. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg tablets price

  25. Pingback: generic cialis 2018 usa

  26. Pingback: buy tadalafil pills

  27. Pingback: visit the website

  28. Pingback: Scott Schulte

  29. Pingback: is fish amoxicillin the same as human

  30. Pingback: devops tools 2021

  31. Pingback: what is amoxicillin 875 mg used for

  32. Pingback: azithromycin for animals

  33. Pingback: celebrex vs naproxen

  34. Pingback: celecoxib or pleacebo

  35. Pingback: cephalexin and spectrum

  36. Pingback: keflex for dogs tooth infection

  37. Pingback: cymbalta generic names

  38. Pingback: duloxetine 60 mg

  39. Pingback: levitra 10mg vs 20mg australia

  40. Pingback: cialis experience australia

  41. Pingback: status of over the counter cialis

  42. Pingback: viagra pornhub

  43. Pingback: buy cialis in australia online

  44. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg prescription

  45. Pingback: buy sildenafil 20 mg online

  46. Pingback: prices buy cialis amazing online

  47. Pingback: viagra buy online india

  48. Pingback: cialis availability in philippines

  49. Pingback: kejuqq

  50. Pingback: where to buy cialis online uk

  51. Pingback: how to buy cialis in dallas otc

  52. Pingback: viagra tablets buying low cost

  53. Pingback: desyrel interactions cialis

  54. Pingback: sildenafilo teva 100 mg comprar

  55. Pingback: buy cialis canada australia

  56. Pingback: vardenafil 75 mg

  57. Pingback: sildenafil price comparison

  58. Pingback: good place to buy cialis online

  59. Pingback: canadian viagra coupon

  60. Pingback: compro sildenafilo

  61. Pingback: sildenafil cost 100mg

  62. Pingback: canada generic viagra price

  63. Pingback: buy tadalafil 20mg price canada

  64. Pingback: viagra generico 25 mg

  65. Pingback: viagra canada fast delivery

  66. Pingback: tadalafil online paypal

  67. Pingback: order sildenafil us

  68. Pingback: cialis and alcohol

  69. Pingback: best otc viagra

  70. Pingback: tadalafil herbal substitute

  71. Pingback: generic viagra sales

  72. Pingback: best tadalafil generic

  73. Pingback: online viagra canada

  74. Pingback: cialis price list

  75. Pingback: real viagra 100mg

  76. Pingback: viamedic cialis

  77. Pingback: rush limbaugh viagra

  78. Pingback: diclofenac sodium side effects

  79. Pingback: online dating northern ireland free

  80. Pingback: adventist totally free dating site

  81. Pingback: dapoxetine medicine price

  82. Pingback: womens viagra

  83. Pingback: buy sildenafil generic

  84. Pingback: cialis alternative

  85. Pingback: sildenafil viagra

  86. Pingback: viagra prescription online

  87. Pingback: sildenafil

  88. Pingback: cheapest generic viagra

  89. Pingback: generic viagra online

  90. Pingback: sildenafil 50mg

  91. Pingback: cialis pharmacy

  92. Pingback: buy cialis online cheap

  93. Pingback: cialis pills

  94. Pingback: cialis usa

  95. Pingback: cialis 5mg

  96. Pingback: how to purchase cialis

  97. Pingback: viagra sale in sydney

  98. Pingback: purchase viagra

  99. Pingback: cheap cialis online no prescription

  100. Pingback: buy viagra online cheapest

  101. Pingback: canadian generic viagra

  102. Pingback: can you split cialis pills

  103. Pingback: cheapest cialis uk

  104. Pingback: viagra online canada

  105. Pingback: cost for generic viagra

  106. Pingback: viagra in india online purchase

  107. Pingback: female cialis

  108. Pingback: viagra online canadian pharmacy

  109. Pingback: viagra sample

  110. Pingback: cialis australia

  111. Pingback: canadian pharmacy viagra

  112. Pingback: sildenafil daily

  113. Pingback: 100mg sildenafil 30 tablets price

  114. Pingback: viagra 37500

  115. Pingback: how much is a cialis pill

  116. Pingback: can i purchase viagra over the counter in canada

  117. Pingback: viagra tablet price in qatar

  118. Pingback: buy viagra in cvs

  119. Pingback: best site for generic viagra

  120. Pingback: viagra and cialis

  121. Pingback: cialis pill

  122. Pingback: can i buy viagra in europe

  123. Pingback: australianviagraonline

  124. Pingback: sildenafil online

  125. Pingback: viagra online prescription free

  126. Pingback: viagra online usa

  127. Pingback: viagra no doctor prescription

  128. Pingback: viagra without a doctors approval

  129. Pingback: viagra tablets australia

  130. Pingback: cost for viagra

  131. Pingback: viagra substitute

  132. Pingback: viagra walmart

  133. Pingback: viagra ohne rezept

  134. Pingback: viagra no prescription

  135. Pingback: cost of viagra per pill

  136. Pingback: order prescription viagra online

  137. Pingback: viagra sildenafil

  138. Pingback: buy viagra online

  139. Pingback: viagra prices

  140. Pingback: walmart viagra

  141. Pingback: viagra pornhub

  142. Pingback: viagra tablet

  143. Pingback: over the counter viagra

  144. Pingback: otc viagra

  145. Pingback: 1confluence

  146. Pingback: natural viagra

  147. Pingback: cialis over the counter

  148. Pingback: buy cialis

  149. Pingback: how to make natural viagra with immediate effect!

  150. Pingback: cost of ivermectin medication

  151. Pingback: ivermectin where to buy

  152. Pingback: ivermectin tablets buy online

  153. Pingback: stromectol (stromectol) for humans

  154. Pingback: stromectol dosing

  155. Pingback: stromectol how much it cost

  156. Pingback: cialis 5mg best price

Leave a Reply